Summer Internship

Several months before a summer vacation, almost every faculty is flooded with email requests for summer internship.  The volumes are so large and the requests are so generic that I just press delete button on those emails.  This phenomena has led me to write this blog to offer some unsolicited advise to students.
Solving difficult academic problems take a large amount of time, typically extending much longer than three months of summer.  If a person is not trained in an area, he/she may not even be able to start on a problem. This is quite common to my area of research, fluid dynamics and turbulence, which is not covered in normal physics curriculum.  Thus, incentive to offer a single internship appears to be a waste of time for both sides, unless the student wishes to continue to work on a mutually agreed upon  project for a longer time after the start (say the next summer).  Unfortunately, most students work on different problems with different guides every summer, hence get no where in terms of real progress.  
Another important thing that every serious student should do is reading interesting books in summer and winter breaks.  To list a few of the classics: 
  1. One, Two, Three,..Infinity: George Gamow, and other books of Gamow
  2. Men of Mathematics: E.T. Bell
  3. Chaos: James Glick
  4. Feynman lectures in Physics: R. P. Feynman
  5. Character of Physical Laws: R. P. Feynman
  6. How to Solve it: G. Polya
  7. Double Helix: J. D. Watson
  8. Popular science, mathematics, and puzzle books by Carl Sagan, Martin Gardner

Reading these books are much more fruitful as well as enjoyable that doing worthless summer projects.  Of course, reading good fiction and non-fiction books are also very thought provoking.
Given above, a meaningful student research project (including summer) should be done in the local institution with professor who has taught a course.  Thus the student is exposed to topic via the course, and the student can approach the professor anytime.  This kind of work can yield a publication.  In my research group, best undergraduate (UG) projects were done this way and they have yielded  research publications in the process.  I believe this is what the best students do in the western countries do.
It is a common practice at present, especially in India, to send generic and often auto-generated emails to hundreds of researchers across the globe.  Many students want to go abroad just for travel sake.  This trend is giving a bad name to the institute, and it should be avoided.  This is not academics!
I do hope this blog is useful for students while deciding what they should do in their summer breaks.


Comments

Unknown said…
This is exactly what I wanted to tell a friend of mine who recently went on a research intern to Japan using the funds of the prof there(which were clearly a part of the research grant) and then roamed around the country and now he is not into research at all! He is busy taking MBA courses here. It is sad indeed. Very well said.
January 12, 2016 at 4:09 AM
कविता रावत said…
आपको जन्मदिन की बहुत-बहुत हार्दिक शुभकामनाएं!
November 9, 2017 at 10:20 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dr. A. P. J. Abdul Kalam Cray HPC award to TARANG

I am happy to share a news that I received Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam  Cray HPC award for the development of  TARANG. The citation reads.. "Development of open-source code TARANG and using it for turbulence simulation at extreme scales”. I thank all contributors to  TARANG.  I have missed many names in my acceptance speech (given below)… but I thank all of you!! The award is really to the whole team who are scattered at many places. 
“Prof. Balakrishnan, Prof. Balaram, Prof. Narasimha, Dr. Di Rose, and members of Cray Computers, I thank you all for the award that means a lot to me and our turbulent group at IIT Kanpur.  Many thanks! I will briefly describe about our code TARANG and its history.  It is a spectral code for solving fluid flows.  Spectral means we use Fourier transforms to resolve a flow at various length scales.  This method is very accurate, and hence it is popular choice for weather modellers. Now, how is TARANG unique?  There are many kinds of flows—with neutra
Read more

Choosing PhD topic and supervisor

"No matter how tough the chase is, you should always have the dream you saw on the first day. It’ll keep you motivated and rescue you from any weak thoughts." ―  Jack Ma “PhD made me poorer, without money, but richer in thoughts.”  ―  Lailah Gifty Akita Many Physics students join a doctoral program with a dream of doing great science. To start well, it is important to choose your PhD research topic and PhD supervisor with care.  In this blog I will try to provide some tips that may help you in this quandary. Which research topic should I choose for my PhD? Statistics show that a majority of academicians continue to work on the same topic as their PhD work for at least 10 years.  Hence, it is prudent to choose your PhD research topic with a proper care.  As I wrote in my blog Should I go for higher eduction in Science & Engineering? ,  I believe that you should choose a topic that interests you most.  This way you will enjoy your work and produce the best results.  But,  h
Read more

On Examinations (addressed to students)

As a teacher, the most annoying things for me are the exams. I believe one should not judge the other person. Every student or scientist is good in something. There could be gradations in aptitudes in various skills like analytic, memory, problem solving, experimental, design etc.  A written exam for several hours is simply not good enough to test various skill.  In fact, it is meaningless to test all the skills,  because typically a person has liking for one or several of these skills. The problem is that the outside world wants to know who are the better students of the class. the award-giving institutions want to know the best students.  Given all these irritating constrains, we award grades and conduct exams.  One may say that the grades are the thing, because we can get the coveted job/scholarship/awards etc. by getting very good grades.  It turns out that if you try to focus too much on grades, you don't tend to learn.  There is a story in this lines.. A student approac
Read more