Individual Liberty

Individual liberty is one of the major pillars of present-day democracy.  It allows an individual to choose profession of his/her liking, have ones own belief system, voice opinion, etc. Individual freedom allowed many creative individuals to chart out their own paths, which led to tremendous creativity and innovation in modern times.  
The alternative, or the old system, is indeed suffocating, at least for the creative individuals; here the system decides the role of an individual.  It is worth noting that the personal liberty over the rights the state and the church over an individual came after a lot of sacrifice; the charter of “Rights of Man”, which outlined these rights for the first time, is a beautiful document to read.
Ref: (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_of_the_Rights_of_Man_and_of_the_Citizen)
An important question is whether we have Individual liberty or not in India?  I believe that the answer is mixed.  In India, the poor do not have appropriate educational opportunities that could enable them to exercise their choices.  They are essentially engaged in manual labour, which is quite exploitative.  For example, house maids in small town earn 600 Rupees per month from a household.  These laborers are not bonded at present, but their conditions are such that they are not in a position to choose a profession of their liking.  
I will add that the present-day government schemes provide wages and food for labour, but they are not skill and intellect enablers.  These schemes remind us of one of the benevolent kings who took care of the subject’s hunger.   Fulfillment of individual freedom requires skill and mind development along with guaranteed food and shelter.
The rich and the middle class have choices for a profession, much more than what was available 30 years ago.  But are the youth choosing what they like? Even more serious, are they or their parents searching within themselves what they like.  We are told in IIT that the parents put tremendous pressure on children to be successful in a conventional sense (become engineer, doctor, manager), but they hardly bother to find out the natural liking of the children. The students too are enthralled by pay packages and western institutions.  This environment is hardly conducive for exercising individual liberty.  The market that claims to provide freedom enchains individuals with greed.  In the market, we have more brands of toothpaste to choose from.  This choice is good, and it does provide freedom of choice, but it is not the freedom of mind.  I do hope more and more students would realize this, and explore their creative aspects, rather than just chasing packages. 
So far, we discussed about individual liberty.  But how does it contribute to the collective? Since a good collective environment is required for exercising individual liberty, we all need to ensure a healthy collective surrounding.  
The market appears to assume that excellence in individual pursuits would somehow add up to yield a healthy collective.  These thoughts, though very attractive, have many counterexamples.  We cannot afford to keep the house clean and dump the garbage on the streets and environment, but which is happening in both rich and poor countries.  Individually brilliant scholars who quarrel among themselves cannot build a school that is required to solve long problems.  Noninteracting neighbours hardly make a good neighborhood.  Two nice but uncompromising individuals would find hard to knit together a happy family. 

  In times of confusion between individual liberty and social responsibility, an interesting quote in Mahabharata comes to my mind: “For the sake of a village, a family should be sacrificed. For the sake of a “country, a village should be sacrificed. For the sake of the soul (I read individual liberty), the earth should be sacrificed.” (Sec. 27, Dyut Parva).  I believe that this stanza it contains valuable advice.   

In summary, we are in need of an excellent collective environment in which all individuals blossom with freedom, but also share collective responsibilities. A simple dream, yet very hard to achieve!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dr. A. P. J. Abdul Kalam Cray HPC award to TARANG

I am happy to share a news that I received Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam  Cray HPC award for the development of  TARANG. The citation reads.. "Development of open-source code TARANG and using it for turbulence simulation at extreme scales”. I thank all contributors to  TARANG.  I have missed many names in my acceptance speech (given below)… but I thank all of you!! The award is really to the whole team who are scattered at many places. 
“Prof. Balakrishnan, Prof. Balaram, Prof. Narasimha, Dr. Di Rose, and members of Cray Computers, I thank you all for the award that means a lot to me and our turbulent group at IIT Kanpur.  Many thanks! I will briefly describe about our code TARANG and its history.  It is a spectral code for solving fluid flows.  Spectral means we use Fourier transforms to resolve a flow at various length scales.  This method is very accurate, and hence it is popular choice for weather modellers. Now, how is TARANG unique?  There are many kinds of flows—with neutra
Read more

Choosing PhD topic and supervisor

"No matter how tough the chase is, you should always have the dream you saw on the first day. It’ll keep you motivated and rescue you from any weak thoughts." ―  Jack Ma “PhD made me poorer, without money, but richer in thoughts.”  ―  Lailah Gifty Akita Many Physics students join a doctoral program with a dream of doing great science. To start well, it is important to choose your PhD research topic and PhD supervisor with care.  In this blog I will try to provide some tips that may help you in this quandary. Which research topic should I choose for my PhD? Statistics show that a majority of academicians continue to work on the same topic as their PhD work for at least 10 years.  Hence, it is prudent to choose your PhD research topic with a proper care.  As I wrote in my blog Should I go for higher eduction in Science & Engineering? ,  I believe that you should choose a topic that interests you most.  This way you will enjoy your work and produce the best results.  But,  h
Read more

On Examinations (addressed to students)

As a teacher, the most annoying things for me are the exams. I believe one should not judge the other person. Every student or scientist is good in something. There could be gradations in aptitudes in various skills like analytic, memory, problem solving, experimental, design etc.  A written exam for several hours is simply not good enough to test various skill.  In fact, it is meaningless to test all the skills,  because typically a person has liking for one or several of these skills. The problem is that the outside world wants to know who are the better students of the class. the award-giving institutions want to know the best students.  Given all these irritating constrains, we award grades and conduct exams.  One may say that the grades are the thing, because we can get the coveted job/scholarship/awards etc. by getting very good grades.  It turns out that if you try to focus too much on grades, you don't tend to learn.  There is a story in this lines.. A student approac
Read more